Fear not Lefty lurkers, I don’t mean that W; I mean the growth curve. It looks as though the porkulus package, as some on the conservative blogosphere have dubbed it, will be pushed through after some rigorous late-night maneuvering. I haven’t read through all of the details of the package, but depending on which news outlet you read and the time of day, cost estimates run anywhere from $780 billion to $926 billion. Only in America can politicians claim to have cut spending while adding to overall costs.
Will it work? For possible answers to that, see my previous post on the Japanese experiment. My own feeling is that it will have a minor placebo-like effect in the short-term; that is to say that it will be difficult to discern if any recovery we experience toward the end of the year was due to the efforts of Washington, or the natural machinations of the business cycle. Whatever the case, the deal appears to have been done, so we need to hunker down and make the most of it.
My concern with the package is more on the longer term impact to the economy. Despite assurances by President Obama and democrats to the contrary, I don’t believe the spending provisions of this bill are “stimulative” at all – many of them appear to be here to stay.
Which leads to the title of my post. While economists appear to be split on which letter of the alphabet the eventual recovery will take – some favoring an “L” and some a “V” – I submit we are more likely to experience a “W”, where short term gains in growth are quickly offset by higher inflation, tightened credit markets and a weaker dollar. At some point, Obama will need to pay for this spending spree – he can raise taxes, take on more debt, or continue to print more money. None of these options is desirable, and may actually be counterproductive to any growth the economy may be experiencing at the time.
With most economists predicting recovery either in the latter part of this year or beginning of next, it wouldn’t be unreasonable to conclude under this scenario that another downturn may be waiting in the wings just about the time Obama gears up for re-election. And with Medicare and Social Security storms on the horizon, we may not be able to spend our way out of that one.
Saturday, February 7, 2009
Fast And The Furious: Tokyo Adrift
I came across this New York Times article by way of Greg Mankiw’s blog. Mankiw is a professor of economics at Harvard University who runs a neat economics blog in his spare time.
When faced with a similar economic downturn in the early 90’s following a real estate bubble, Japan embarked on its own program of massive spending on public works.
Did it work? The answer, frustratingly but not surprisingly is maybe. After all, this is economics we’re talking about. After over a decade of spending, Japan accumulated the largest public in the developed world, but has recorded anemic growth to show for it.
But since Congress appears determined to take us over these falls, the story does provide some interesting lessons as to where and how to spend. Are you taking any notes, Rep. Obey?
When faced with a similar economic downturn in the early 90’s following a real estate bubble, Japan embarked on its own program of massive spending on public works.
Did it work? The answer, frustratingly but not surprisingly is maybe. After all, this is economics we’re talking about. After over a decade of spending, Japan accumulated the largest public in the developed world, but has recorded anemic growth to show for it.
But since Congress appears determined to take us over these falls, the story does provide some interesting lessons as to where and how to spend. Are you taking any notes, Rep. Obey?
Friday, February 6, 2009
Obama’s Bully Pulpit Or Just Plain Bull?
Striking a slightly angrier rhetorical tone yesterday, President Barack Obama warned the American people that failure to enact his stimulus package could result in irreversible economic hardships. Interestingly, that’s just what I would say about passage of this heaping pile of crap.
Writing in an Op-Ed piece in Thursday’s Washington Post, Obama sought to reinforce the dire straits the US faces: “This recession might linger for years. Our economy will lose 5 million more jobs. Unemployment will approach double digits. Our nation will sink deeper into a crisis that, at some point, we may not be able to reverse.”
Obama also rejected traditional stimulus measures such as tax cuts to help jump start the economy. “I reject these theories,” said Obama, “and so did the American people when they went to the polls in November and voted resoundingly for change.”
Here, I think Obama may be in danger of misreading the American public’s desire for and the scope of his mandate for change. The financial market meltdown last Fall provided democrats with their own version of an “October Surprise”, sealing the deal for voters weary of eight years of republican executive management. Americans elected Obama largely because he sounded like the fiscally conservative grown up in the room, at least among independents. And as deficit projections from the proposed stimulus and financial bailouts balloon to over $2 trillion, with much of the spending provisions remaining a permanent fixture of federal spending, Americans are understandably nervous.
The president then promptly blamed republicans for holding up the package in Congress. In a speech before the party elite later in the day, Obama slammed the Bush Administration for running up the national debt, and mocked republicans for questioning the stimulative aspects of the package – “What do they think stimulus is, it’s spending!” But Democrats are firmly in the driver’s seat here and should have the votes necessary to pass the bill without republican support. And surely a bill that adds almost a $1 trillion to the public debt should be carefully reviewed, shouldn’t it?
Clearly, things are not going Obama's way. He needs to wrestle control of the debate back from the more left leaning elements of the party and recast it in a more bi-partisan and less fatalistic fashion. Wasn’t this type of fear-mongering the same tactic President Obama accused his opposition of relying upon during the campaign?
Writing in an Op-Ed piece in Thursday’s Washington Post, Obama sought to reinforce the dire straits the US faces: “This recession might linger for years. Our economy will lose 5 million more jobs. Unemployment will approach double digits. Our nation will sink deeper into a crisis that, at some point, we may not be able to reverse.”
Obama also rejected traditional stimulus measures such as tax cuts to help jump start the economy. “I reject these theories,” said Obama, “and so did the American people when they went to the polls in November and voted resoundingly for change.”
Here, I think Obama may be in danger of misreading the American public’s desire for and the scope of his mandate for change. The financial market meltdown last Fall provided democrats with their own version of an “October Surprise”, sealing the deal for voters weary of eight years of republican executive management. Americans elected Obama largely because he sounded like the fiscally conservative grown up in the room, at least among independents. And as deficit projections from the proposed stimulus and financial bailouts balloon to over $2 trillion, with much of the spending provisions remaining a permanent fixture of federal spending, Americans are understandably nervous.
The president then promptly blamed republicans for holding up the package in Congress. In a speech before the party elite later in the day, Obama slammed the Bush Administration for running up the national debt, and mocked republicans for questioning the stimulative aspects of the package – “What do they think stimulus is, it’s spending!” But Democrats are firmly in the driver’s seat here and should have the votes necessary to pass the bill without republican support. And surely a bill that adds almost a $1 trillion to the public debt should be carefully reviewed, shouldn’t it?
Clearly, things are not going Obama's way. He needs to wrestle control of the debate back from the more left leaning elements of the party and recast it in a more bi-partisan and less fatalistic fashion. Wasn’t this type of fear-mongering the same tactic President Obama accused his opposition of relying upon during the campaign?
Gibbs Can't Dance
Poor Robert Gibbs. Obama’s Press Secretary has had a lot of tap dancing to do before the press regarding recent cabinet nominee tax, um, oversights.
Presidential press relations is a hard, thankless job, and Gibbs is clearly not up to it as evidenced in this tête-à-tête with Jake Tapper:
Check out the look on Helen Thomas’ face about a minute into it – she looks like an angry Lasso Apso poised to gnaw off Tapper’s nose for daring to question the transparency of The One.
Gibbs will be replaced by the end of the month; not a good sign for the Administration.
Presidential press relations is a hard, thankless job, and Gibbs is clearly not up to it as evidenced in this tête-à-tête with Jake Tapper:
Check out the look on Helen Thomas’ face about a minute into it – she looks like an angry Lasso Apso poised to gnaw off Tapper’s nose for daring to question the transparency of The One.
Gibbs will be replaced by the end of the month; not a good sign for the Administration.
Wednesday, February 4, 2009
Executive Wage Controls
President Obama is said to be seriously considering rules that would seek to impose a $500,000 a year salary cap on executives whose firms receive government financial rescue funds. The rules are expected to be announced next week as part of a plan to spend the remaining TARP funds.
I reserve the right to reverse course once I see the complete details of the rules, but based upon the preliminary details, I’m a’gin it. The same argument that has been made to me about congressional pay (enticing the “best and brightest” to public service and all that) applies here. No one batted an eyelash when these executives were at the helm of institutions that were returning 20% on investment five years ago. And considering bad governmental policy and lax oversight are at the heart of the current mess, this strikes me as a bit hypocritical on the part of Congress.
How so? Take a look at these congressional perks, courtesy of the National Taxpayers Union:
- Pension benefits that are two to three times more generous than those offered in the private sector for similarly-salaried executives. Taxpayers directly cover at least 80 percent of this costly plan. Congressional pensions are also inflation-protected, a feature that fewer than 1 in 10 private plans offer.
- Health and life insurance, approximately 3/4 and 1/3 of whose costs, respectively, are subsidized by taxpayers.
- Wheeled perks, including limousines for senior Members, prized parking spaces on Capitol Hill, and choice spots at Washington's two major airports.
- Travel to far-flung destinations as well as to home states and districts. Despite recent attempts to toughen gift and travel rules, "junkets" are still readily available prerogatives for many Members.
- A wide range of smaller perks that have defied reform efforts, from cut-rate health clubs to fine furnishings.
If we're doing the whole Bolshevik thing here, we ought to go full-bore. I look forward to Obama’s plan to address these inequities.
Look, if you don’t like what the CEO of CitiGroup or whatever it’s called this morning makes, then don’t invest in it. Information on executive compensation is widely available to investors; in fact, executive pay is often put before shareholders vote.
But governmental intrusion and wage controls will only exacerbate the problem by attracting less qualified applicants to head these institutions “too big to fail”. They also amount to the classic slippery slope argument. What’s next, capping salaries for surgeons and other medical professionals – do you really want to go under the knife of a guy who suddenly makes minimum wage?
I reserve the right to reverse course once I see the complete details of the rules, but based upon the preliminary details, I’m a’gin it. The same argument that has been made to me about congressional pay (enticing the “best and brightest” to public service and all that) applies here. No one batted an eyelash when these executives were at the helm of institutions that were returning 20% on investment five years ago. And considering bad governmental policy and lax oversight are at the heart of the current mess, this strikes me as a bit hypocritical on the part of Congress.
How so? Take a look at these congressional perks, courtesy of the National Taxpayers Union:
- Pension benefits that are two to three times more generous than those offered in the private sector for similarly-salaried executives. Taxpayers directly cover at least 80 percent of this costly plan. Congressional pensions are also inflation-protected, a feature that fewer than 1 in 10 private plans offer.
- Health and life insurance, approximately 3/4 and 1/3 of whose costs, respectively, are subsidized by taxpayers.
- Wheeled perks, including limousines for senior Members, prized parking spaces on Capitol Hill, and choice spots at Washington's two major airports.
- Travel to far-flung destinations as well as to home states and districts. Despite recent attempts to toughen gift and travel rules, "junkets" are still readily available prerogatives for many Members.
- A wide range of smaller perks that have defied reform efforts, from cut-rate health clubs to fine furnishings.
If we're doing the whole Bolshevik thing here, we ought to go full-bore. I look forward to Obama’s plan to address these inequities.
Look, if you don’t like what the CEO of CitiGroup or whatever it’s called this morning makes, then don’t invest in it. Information on executive compensation is widely available to investors; in fact, executive pay is often put before shareholders vote.
But governmental intrusion and wage controls will only exacerbate the problem by attracting less qualified applicants to head these institutions “too big to fail”. They also amount to the classic slippery slope argument. What’s next, capping salaries for surgeons and other medical professionals – do you really want to go under the knife of a guy who suddenly makes minimum wage?
Obama's War
The Wall Street Journal is reporting that the Obama Administration and senior military commanders are putting the finishing touches on plans to deploy tens of thousands of troops to Afghanistan by summer’s end in an effort to quell an upswing in violence in recent years, and reign in the re-emerging influence of the Taliban.
Virtually none of the new troop deployments are expected to head to the more populous regions of the country, but will instead focus on Afghanistan’s opium producing centers, rural villages and along the border with Pakistan.
This Afghan “surge” is in part President Obama’s response to his campaign pledge to refocus the US war on terror (or whatever the administration chooses to call it today) away from Iraq and toward the troubled regions of Afghanistan and Pakistan. Strategically, it’s a wise and long-overdue move; tactically, it will represent a significant shift from current methods of waging war – a shift for which I’m not quite sure the American public is prepared.
The speed and efficiency with which the US toppled the Taliban in 2002 surprised even its planners. Victory was accomplished through the coordinated effort of special forces and the CIA, making what would amount to be unholy alliances with some very unsavory characters. It’s easy enough to get them to kill themselves, harder still to get them to govern themselves.
During the run up to the Iraq war and its aftermath, democrats played the safe bet by criticizing the war without appearing to criticize the mission. The good and just war, they argued, was in Afghanistan – after all, that’s where the 9/11 plot was hatched.
Now, they have their wish. But the front has shifted to a region best described by war correspondent Michael Yon:
Afghanistan is a gaunt, thorny bush, growing amid rocks and dust on dry windswept plains, sweltering deserts, and man-crushing mountains. Its neighbors are treacherous. The Afghan people are mostly living relics, only more advanced than hidden tribes in the Amazon, but centuries behind the least advanced European nations.
Afghanistan is a gaunt, thorny bush, subsisting on little more than sips of humidity from the dry air. We imagined that we could make the bush into a tree, as if straw could be spun into gold or rocks transmuted to flowers. If we continue to imagine that we can turn the thorny bush into a tree, eventually we will realize the truth, but only after much toil, blood and gold are laid under the bush, as if such fertilizer would turn a bush into a tree. We did not make Afghanistan what it is. Afghanistan has existed for thousands of years. It grows the way it grows because the bush drops seeds that make more bushes, never trees.
We must alter our expectations for Afghanistan. There are bigger problems afoot. The ice is melting, banks are melting, and the prestige of great nations that do great things is melting, because they thought they could transform a thorny bush into a tree.
Alter our expectations indeed – speaking on CBS last Sunday, Vice President Biden sought to do just that: “I hate to say it, but yes, I think there will be more [US casualties]…there will be an uptick.”
In addition to altering these expectations, it is my hope that Obama and his advisors will suspend their disbelief long enough to LISTEN to their military advisors on the ground. It’s going to be hard, it’s going to be long and it will be costly.
Virtually none of the new troop deployments are expected to head to the more populous regions of the country, but will instead focus on Afghanistan’s opium producing centers, rural villages and along the border with Pakistan.
This Afghan “surge” is in part President Obama’s response to his campaign pledge to refocus the US war on terror (or whatever the administration chooses to call it today) away from Iraq and toward the troubled regions of Afghanistan and Pakistan. Strategically, it’s a wise and long-overdue move; tactically, it will represent a significant shift from current methods of waging war – a shift for which I’m not quite sure the American public is prepared.
The speed and efficiency with which the US toppled the Taliban in 2002 surprised even its planners. Victory was accomplished through the coordinated effort of special forces and the CIA, making what would amount to be unholy alliances with some very unsavory characters. It’s easy enough to get them to kill themselves, harder still to get them to govern themselves.
During the run up to the Iraq war and its aftermath, democrats played the safe bet by criticizing the war without appearing to criticize the mission. The good and just war, they argued, was in Afghanistan – after all, that’s where the 9/11 plot was hatched.
Now, they have their wish. But the front has shifted to a region best described by war correspondent Michael Yon:
Afghanistan is a gaunt, thorny bush, growing amid rocks and dust on dry windswept plains, sweltering deserts, and man-crushing mountains. Its neighbors are treacherous. The Afghan people are mostly living relics, only more advanced than hidden tribes in the Amazon, but centuries behind the least advanced European nations.
Afghanistan is a gaunt, thorny bush, subsisting on little more than sips of humidity from the dry air. We imagined that we could make the bush into a tree, as if straw could be spun into gold or rocks transmuted to flowers. If we continue to imagine that we can turn the thorny bush into a tree, eventually we will realize the truth, but only after much toil, blood and gold are laid under the bush, as if such fertilizer would turn a bush into a tree. We did not make Afghanistan what it is. Afghanistan has existed for thousands of years. It grows the way it grows because the bush drops seeds that make more bushes, never trees.
We must alter our expectations for Afghanistan. There are bigger problems afoot. The ice is melting, banks are melting, and the prestige of great nations that do great things is melting, because they thought they could transform a thorny bush into a tree.
Alter our expectations indeed – speaking on CBS last Sunday, Vice President Biden sought to do just that: “I hate to say it, but yes, I think there will be more [US casualties]…there will be an uptick.”
In addition to altering these expectations, it is my hope that Obama and his advisors will suspend their disbelief long enough to LISTEN to their military advisors on the ground. It’s going to be hard, it’s going to be long and it will be costly.
Danny DeVito Arrested In Baghdad?

Oops, mistaken identity; it’s not Danny DeVito, just “The Mother of Believers”, 50 year-old Baghdad resident Samira Ahmed Jassim who stands accused of recruiting dozens of female suicide bombers and masterminding 28 attacks in the region.
The plot goes something like this – young women were purposely raped and sent to Jassim for motherly advice. Jassim is then allegedly said to have counseled these women to become suicide bombers as the only escape from their shame and to reclaim their honor.
I keep looking for evidence of the whole “religion of peace” thing, but I’m not finding any.
The plot goes something like this – young women were purposely raped and sent to Jassim for motherly advice. Jassim is then allegedly said to have counseled these women to become suicide bombers as the only escape from their shame and to reclaim their honor.
I keep looking for evidence of the whole “religion of peace” thing, but I’m not finding any.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)